A very anticipated album just released a week or so ago – Even In Arcadia by everyone’s favorite non-metal metal band or dark pop band or *checks Wikipedia* alt/prog/post-metal indie pop R&B band, Sleep Token.
Based on a first couple of listens… it’s fine. I have more to add – first let me yap a bit for content, then I’ll give the real details.
I first discovered Sleep Token when The Algorithm recommended I watch the video for Alkaline.
Isn’t that sick? (I mean, it’s like 4 years old now, so you’re either well aware or have probably already decided you don’t care, but whatever.)
So anyway, I downloaded This Place Will Become Your Tomb, which had a lot of neat tracks. The opener, Atlantic, is really powerful, and I still love Alkaline. Every once in a while, parts of Distraction or Descending pop into my head for seemingly no reason.
Then, singles started dropping from the follow-up (and ending to the initial Sleep Token “trilogy”), Take Me Back to Eden. Each one was pretty incredible, and the entire album is, if I dare say, a masterpiece. (Most reviews are absolutely glowing, and the harsh ones tend to either point out how long it is or just how much it seems to be trying to do, which I think are its selling points.)
The first singles (also the first tracks on the album, probably not coincidentally) Chokehold and The Summoning are a pretty good intro into what’s going on here. Chokehold has some heavy rock riffs with a clean, possibly “pretty” vocal on top. The Summoning starts out heavy, then about 2 minutes in, the background turns sort of ethereal, then there’s what I guess you could call a breakdown, but on an organ? And then it closes with like an R&B sex jam?
Anyway, the rest of the album is like this. There’s a track called Aqua Regia which I guess is the album’s follow up to Alkaline – it’s a love song describing one’s feelings in terms of chemical reactions. Then, the centerpiece of the album is Ascensionism, that starts with piano and a sort of haunting vocal, then switches up to a trap beat and rapping, then a section that I can really only describe as “grand”, then some metal screams, and then an outro that mirrors the intro. It’s a lot. How do they cram all that into one song? It’s over 7 minutes long, that’s how!
As the album proceeds, all of the various elements are assembled and reassembled in different arrangements. Each song is unique, but also distinctly sounds like Sleep Token. I would say the album defines the band’s identity (for good and bad).
Now why did I just spend four paragraphs describing an album that isn’t the one this post is about? Because honestly, where Take Me Back to Eden was surprising, and groundbreaking, and refreshing, Even In Arcadia is familiar and orderly and kinda boring.
I’ve listened to it straight through a few times, but I’m going to do it again now as I write this and give some track-by-track notes. (I’m not a music reviewer; my opinions are meaningless, but they are mine, and so I will spout them as if they are correct.)
Look to Windward
This is a nice opener. It’s got a weird intro I can’t quite describe, then a soft vocal that gets to the hook line and repeats it just enough to really burn it into your brain. Then an… interlude? followed by another verse, just a little bit louder. This is building to something… oh, Vessel whispers the hook line and then the instrumental explodes into a metal breakdown. Yeah, it’s cool. It’s what I expect in a Sleep Token song now. And then a trap beat and rapping. Neat. And we close out on some guitars, some falsetto vocals, and then some of that “ethereal” backing over whispers, and then the breakdown again. This is a good track, but it almost seems like it’s a redo of The Summoning or some other tracks from TMBTE.
Emergence
This was the first single off of the album, and it’s getting radio play (at least on satellite radio, no idea about terrestrial), so maybe you’re already aware. It starts with piano and Vessel doing a nice, clean, simple vocal. Guy can sing. Then we have this downshifted repeating hook (or maybe a backup vocalist), and then we’re into the rapping. It’s fun; the lines are pretty memorable and the flow is cool. After the hook again, we’re back into the rap, but this time the beat is replaced by the guitars. It’s an interesting little change. Similarly, we repeat the opening vocal, but with the full instrumental over it instead of just the piano. And then this one moment – it’s so dumb, but so fun and goes so hard. The whole video is embedded, but just play it for a few seconds.
That WHOOOP is so fuckin’ weird. Anyway, cool song. This was a good single. Oh, and it ends on a saxophone solo. Hell yeah.
Past Self
This one opens starts with… raps? There’s a certain vocal flow, but there’s not really a “beat”; maybe this song is more “R&B” styled… ok, if Vessel wasn’t “rapping” before, then at about 0:42, he definitely is.
This is nice. It’s definitely more pop-oriented, with perhaps a little dig at the over-obsessed fans with a line about “true believers that turned out to be faithless”. It’s a fun little bop. (I say “little” because it’s about half the length of either of the previous tracks.)
Dangerous
This one is downtempo. The closest comparison from TMBTE is maybe a less repetitive DYWTYLM. About a minute and a half in, a sort of electronic bit kicks in with like WHOOPs but digital, like a single tone of an alarm or something. It’s a good track, but the slower vocal makes this track feel like it drags, even though it’s only about 4 minutes long.
Caramel
This was the second single. “Stick to me like caramel” sounds like it should be a line from one of the sex jams, but it’s not. This song is about how Vessel hates that the fan base keeps trying to tear down his anonymity while he’s just trying to make music, but he does genuinely enjoy the fact that people like what they’re doing.
Musically, it’s a pretty poppy song, with a driving metal breakdown about 3 and a half minutes in. It’s a good emotional hit, and it’s easy to see that what Vessel describes feeling in the song as real, since some of the band’s dealings with the fans are well documented at this point. (Compared to, say, Atlantic from TPWBYT, which is a song about surviving a suicide attempt. I don’t know if Vessel has actually been through that, but I do know that fans don’t want to let him just be Vessel.)
Even In Arcadia
This is not the banger that the title track of TMBTE was. (It’s also not over 8 minutes long like that one was.) It’s shorter, at least vocally (the lyrics page on Genius can just about display the whole thing on my laptop screen without scrolling), but the slow tempo stretches it out temporally and accentuates the emotion of the song. I’m not 100% on what that emotion is, but it’s powerful and will probably resonate differently for different people.
Provider
This one’s a love song, but instead of like Alkaline where Vessel sings about how perfect the person he’s in love with is, it’s about how he just wants to give them everything, but then also the lyrics explain that these two have already been together, and so this not about pursuing the object of one’s affection, but getting back together with an ex. (TMBTE had a lot of lyrics about realizing that a relationship was bad and coming to terms with loving someone by way of letting them be happy somewhere else and growing as a person without them, so maybe this is a continuation of that “lore”.)
Damocles
This was the third single released, but I didn’t listen to it until the album came out. It’s sort of a follow-up to Caramel, but where Caramel is about how Vessel is torn between the pressures of performing for millions of adoring fans and the satisfaction of knowing those fans are there to hear what he’s making, Damocles is about how fame could come crashing down at any time, leaving one’s life in ruin, and how you might not even be able to tell that it’s happening.
Musically, it’s a pretty song, feeling a lot like Euclid from TMBTE. (Interestingly, Euclid ended that album and called all the way back to the opening of Sundowning, bringing to a close not just the album, but essentially the whole trilogy.)
Gethsemane
This is another “here’s how I’m doing after our relationship” song. (Which is what Euclid was about on TMBTE.) That is the recurring theme throughout the Sleep Token discography, a lot of “I’m broken up that we’re not a thing anymore, but it wasn’t working anyway and I’m getting better” intertwined with “ACTUALLY I AM NOT GETTING BETTER AT ALL”. (In fact, one of the lines in Caramel is “I thought I got better, but maybe I didn’t.”)
Musically, now that I’m sitting here reading the lyrics and playing through parts of it repeatedly… wow. This hits me the way Euclid does. The lyrics are sad, the delivery just emphasis how sad they are, and the instrumental is there just enough to pull everything along. It kind of sounds upbeat, almost like the song itself is putting on that mask of telling you everything is fine while holding back tears.
And there’s a riff in the middle right around the chorus that sounds like the one in Euclid around the “Do you remember me when the rain gathers?” line. As I sit here parsing the whole thing, that just pushed me over the edge.
But then, in sort of typical Sleep Token fashion, the whole vibe changes and we get what essentially feels like a different song. When we have a rock song with a pop verse, it still feels like it fits, but a slow, soft song that absolutely just rips your heart out doesn’t need the shift here. Or maybe it does, to pull you back from that edge, right before ending on “…even though it’s over now, I will always be reminded.”
Infinite Baths
Ok, that last song feels like it should have been the ending, if only because it’s so much like Euclid that I want to go out on that note like TMBTE did.
But we have this “encore” (I guess sort of like how the title track was the “ending” of TMBTE and then Euclid followed it) song. It’s hopeful; there’s a lot of “I know how much worse things could be, and I’m fighting to stay above that”. Then we have a screaming breakdown that’s nearly incomprehensible. (I say “nearly” because with the lyrics in front of me, I can decipher it. It’s like the screaming parts of Vore in that the distortion of the vocal coupled with the sheer volume of the instrumental that makes it almost hard to tell there’s even a vocal present.) And the last line of said breakdown is “I will be what I am.” – defiant in its delivery. And then we go out on about a minute of heavy instrumental. (The sort of thing people have probably been waiting for a bit now, maybe the whole album.)
Going track by track, giving each one a more careful listen and reading the lyrics alongside, every song is somewhere between fine and great. So why does the album feel so underwhelming when you put it on in the car and listen to it straight through?
First, I think the songs kind of demand a careful listen. I think they’re dealing with some heavy stuff, and if you aren’t giving it your full attention, you just get the vibes, and the vibes are weird.
Second, if you look at those track-by-track notes, there’s a lot of “oh, this is like Euclid” or “this is like The Summoning.” Even in Arcadia doesn’t feel like another chapter (because the story “ended” already), but it also doesn’t feel like the opening of a new one. It feels like an epilogue. (And maybe it is; maybe this is the band putting out some thoughts and feelings while they work on a new story. Some of these tracks feel like they could have fit in TMBTE, so maybe they were discarded, or are like B-sides and were put together here.)
Third, I think Sleep Token is leaning a lot more on a “formula” that came out of the response to TMBTE. I feel like, not only are the songs mostly arrangements of the same pieces (the pretty vocals, the heavy breakdowns, the trap verses), but on this album, there’s no surprise or novelty to it anymore. When you think Vessel is going to start rapping, he does. When you think they’re going to drop in a loud guitar section, they do.
There is some new territory here. Musically, there’s some more electronic vibes in a couple of places, and thematically, there’s a lot more about how the band themselves are grappling with what their sudden, incredible success is doing to them as people, and also how their desire for anonymity doesn’t really let them deal with that. (But doctor, I AM Vessel…)
So yeah, if you think Sleep Token is overrated, or you hate them because they’re in the rock and metal scene despite featuring other musical styles more predominantly, then this album isn’t changing your mind. If you like Sleep Token because you like mashing genres together and weird vibes, then you’re getting more of that here. However, if Take Me Back to Eden grabbed your attention because just how different it was, Even in Arcadia isn’t going to bowl you over the same way.
It’s fine.